Is The 80/20 Rule For Nutrition & Exercise A Myth?

by | July 29, 2019

Is The 80/20 Rule For Nutrition & Exercise A Myth?

Have you heard of the 80/20 rule when it comes to health & fitness?

You may have heard that abs are made in the kitchen...

Or you may have eaten an extra piece of dessert because you exercised that day, so you feel like you “earned” it dammit!

In order to see results at the gym, lose weight or even maintain overall health, we’re told that it’s an 80/20 balance. Meaning 80% of your results comes from the food you eat and only 20% of your results come from your workouts.

But is this actually true? ...that food is THAT much more important than exercise when it comes to our health and our results in performance?

Well, it all depends on your goals. Hang in there with me now because it’s going to get good!

 

Health Goal: FAT LOSS

THE VERDICT? 80/20 Nutrition to Exercise ratio

Have you ever eaten a cookie or other sweet treat after your workout and thought “I earned this, so I’m going for it!”

So many people assume that just because they’re exercising, they can eat whatever they want. This simply isn’t true if your goal is FAT LOSS. While exercise has tremendous health benefits, nutrition plays a bigger role in helping you shed the extra weight and inches.

Most people eat at least 21 times in a week. And if we’re regularly exercising, that means we’re working out between 3-6 times a week. (Look at me with the math!)

Just looking at those numbers alone, it’s obvious that WHAT we eat is going to have a bigger impact on our waistline.

Now that doesn’t mean we should simply stop exercising! It just means you’ve got to get really serious about HOW and WHAT you’re fueling your body with.

So, if your top priority is FAT LOSS, exercise is still important. But if you’re eating fast food and chocolate because you think you’ve “earned it”, you’re just not going to see the results you want to achieve in terms of changes in body composition.

Health Goal: OPTIMIZED HEALTH & LONGEVITY

THE VERDICT? 50/50 Nutrition to Exercise ratio

It goes without saying that BOTH exercise and nutrition are important factors for overall health status. The food that we eat most certainly has an impact on our overall health and longevity.

As a matter of fact, exercise has been proven to boost mental health, reduce risk of chronic diseases, strengthen your bones and muscles and help you live longer (to name a few!).

One study in particular found that a combination of exercise and nutrition provided the best results for achieving long term fat loss.

But, on the whole - why is food & nutrition more important in the bigger health picture?

The reason that a healthful daily diet is so much more effective than exercise on the whole, is because it takes a ton of activity to create a 500 to 700 calorie deficit through working out.

Essentially, you’d need to run 11 - 16 km a day to lose 500g in a week, says Holly Lofton, M.D., an assistant professor of medicine at New York University's Langone Medical Center.

As you can imagine, the average person simply can’t keep this up, especially without increasing their caloric intake. So then you’re simply back where you started.

So, we should just stop exercising and focus all of our energy on our daily diet?

No, of course not…

What’s most important is that you’re moving your body and eating nutrient dense food on a regular basis. You can’t go wrong with this strategy for overall health.

However if your goals change, it may mean that you focus a little more on one or the other in order to achieve the individual results you want. But it doesn’t have to be all or nothing!

You can still achieve results, maintain good health and enjoy delicious tasting food. It’s best to focus on food with real ingredients (whole foods!) as much as possible, and you can even create your own “healthified” dessert or high energy snack.

These 2-ingredient Almond Butter Stuffed Dates are the perfect way to satisfy a sweet tooth without adding processed sugar. Plus, they are high in fibre and healthy fats and they taste decadent!

 

REFERENCES

[1] Centers for Disease Control & Prevention: Physical Activity & Health - The Benefits of Physical Activity

[2] Journal of the Academy of Nutrition & Dietetics: Diet or Exercise Interventions vs Combined Behavioural Weight Management Programs

[3] Women’s Health Mag: 7 Things No One Ever Tells You About Running a Half-Marathon

 

 

Recent Posts

7 Simple Ways To Eat More Mindfully

7 Simple Ways To Eat More Mindfully

As a nutrition coach I focus on habits and behaviours – and the first habit I introduce to clients is mindful eating. We’re often told WHAT to eat… what types of foods, how much of them, what combinations, and what time to eat them – all with the...

Exercising with Chronic Pain

Exercising with Chronic Pain

Exercising is good for you, for so many reasons – physically & mentally.  This isn’t new information – the benefits of exercise have been well researched and reported. But what if you are living with chronic pain (i.e. pain that lasts longer than...

 Almond Butter Stuffed Dates

 Almond Butter Stuffed Dates

 Almond Butter Stuffed Dates  Ingredients  12 Medjool Dates (no sulphites) 12 tsp Almond Butter (no added sugar or oil) Optional Toppings: unsweetened shredded coconut, pomegranate seeds, chia seeds, hemp hearts, cinnamon and/or a pinch of sea salt Preparation  Create...

7 Hormone Balancing Lifestyle & Diet Tips

7 Hormone Balancing Lifestyle & Diet Tips

Menopause is a normal, natural life event that occurs when a woman’s period stops. It commonly happens between the ages of 40 and 58. Smokers can start menopause up to 2 years earlier than non-smokers. Menopause happens because the ovaries naturally stop producing the...

Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | © 2019 Real Girls

Designed by Karine Marie

Pin It on Pinterest

Shares
Share This